Posted By: Gripped
Living under the shadow of the Golf - 19/05/2016 22:26
I was reminded today when I glanced in the rear view mirror at a new Astra, of how car makers try to emulate the appeal of the VW Golf.
The obvious one, being VW themselves, who are so scared of ruining the image, that each iteration of Golf looks painfully similar to the last, for fear of alienating their VW badge worshiping cult.
Ford seems to have avoided it to some degree (although the Asbo era Focus was a bit VW ish). The first Focus was a complete breath of fresh air compared to the tired old Escort, and each new Focus is markedly different to the last. Now, Ford are emulating Aston Martin with their gaping grille. Almost trying to avoid VW-ness entirely.
Vauxhall have done ok (albeit in their own dowdy way) avoiding the Golf template until the new facelift model Astra, which bears more than a passing resemblance to the latest gen golf.
Even Fiat succumbed in the (IMO) with the Stilo, having a more Coulthard square jawed VW image, which was completely at odds with the feminine lines of the outgoing Bravo.
Then there is the way that VW, Ford and Vauxhall (GM) have arm wrestled over handing, quality, speed and desirability. The MK1 Focus set the standard for handling and brave design, Vauxhall took their time, but focussed (excuse the pun) on interior quality and all roundness... eventually matching the handling, and VW started fixing the handling after the MkIV era Golf, which was made of granite, but handled like a barge. The surprise, is that the new Astra (according to the mags) is better than the Golf and the Focus. Yet for me, the Astra has gone so Golfy, they look dull.
Any views?
The obvious one, being VW themselves, who are so scared of ruining the image, that each iteration of Golf looks painfully similar to the last, for fear of alienating their VW badge worshiping cult.
Ford seems to have avoided it to some degree (although the Asbo era Focus was a bit VW ish). The first Focus was a complete breath of fresh air compared to the tired old Escort, and each new Focus is markedly different to the last. Now, Ford are emulating Aston Martin with their gaping grille. Almost trying to avoid VW-ness entirely.
Vauxhall have done ok (albeit in their own dowdy way) avoiding the Golf template until the new facelift model Astra, which bears more than a passing resemblance to the latest gen golf.
Even Fiat succumbed in the (IMO) with the Stilo, having a more Coulthard square jawed VW image, which was completely at odds with the feminine lines of the outgoing Bravo.
Then there is the way that VW, Ford and Vauxhall (GM) have arm wrestled over handing, quality, speed and desirability. The MK1 Focus set the standard for handling and brave design, Vauxhall took their time, but focussed (excuse the pun) on interior quality and all roundness... eventually matching the handling, and VW started fixing the handling after the MkIV era Golf, which was made of granite, but handled like a barge. The surprise, is that the new Astra (according to the mags) is better than the Golf and the Focus. Yet for me, the Astra has gone so Golfy, they look dull.
Any views?