Fiat Coupe Club UK

Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump

Posted By: Anonymous

Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 20/03/2006 18:06

Does anyone know if the impedance of the walbro 255 pump is higher than the O/E pump?

I've noticed some people only seem to get a voltage drop under high load with the 255 pump, and not with the O/E pump using the same wiring and no voltage mod.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 20/03/2006 18:44

Don't know on top of my head, but I can check it out later today.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 20/03/2006 19:59

thanks Jim - would be great if you could.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 20/03/2006 20:01

Quote:

I've noticed some people only seem to get a voltage drop under high load with the 255 pump, and not with the O/E pump using the same wiring and no voltage mod.




hi suba,

you've tested this ?

Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 12:05

Measured my OE pump, about 4.6 ohm. Then I was about to measure on the Walbro one, though it's in the tank and I couldn't be bothtered with removing it.
Instead I took the measurement on the connector in the lid, and I really belive that I got something wrong. The resistance was about 0.6-0.7 ohm, which includes both the pump and the short piece of wire inside the tank.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 14:08

Quote:

Quote:

I've noticed some people only seem to get a voltage drop under high load with the 255 pump, and not with the O/E pump using the same wiring and no voltage mod.




hi suba,

you've tested this ?






No, but Barbz had exactly this happen on my car .

Phil
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 15:59

Same on my car - I got fuelling probelms AFTER fitting the 255 pump, that I did not have before (though unfortunately I dont know if there were other contributing factors). we know the walbro 255 pump is not designed for the coupe - so I'm trying to find out what needs / does not need to be done in order to use it efficiently on our cars.

here's my current understanding - anyone that knows better please correct me!

the O/E fuelling system is designed to drop the voltage when the fuel rail is fully pressurised and under load to reduce strain on the pump and also get more power at the top end from leaning out the mixture slightly.

On paper the Walbro pump supplies more fuel - however if this pump has a higher impedance than the O/E pump then any voltage drop could be exagerated and less fuel will be supplied. How much less? - I dont know, but is it feasible that to upgrade to a 255lr pump on the standard wiring / power supply could result in less / the same fuel getting to the rail under high demand than with the O/E pump?


Jim - thanks for checking the O/E pump. Does anyone have a Walbro 255 pump that they have not installed yet that they could check the impedance of? Not being lazy - but I'd rather not have to take mine out of the car to check it myself...
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 16:32

Quote:

Measured my OE pump, about 4.6 ohm. Then I was about to measure on the Walbro one, though it's in the tank and I couldn't be bothtered with removing it.
Instead I took the measurement on the connector in the lid, and I really belive that I got something wrong. The resistance was about 0.6-0.7 ohm, which includes both the pump and the short piece of wire inside the tank.




You need to isolate the pump from the wiring to measure impedance as all you are measuring is the resistance of the wiring if its still connected.

Im not convinced that voltage will be dropped to the pump on high loads. I maybe wrong but I dont think you can control a DC pump in this way and there is no mechanism in the ECU to do this. AFAIK the voltage supply is constant but as the pump delivers more flow the voltage will drop as the pump draws more current to do more work.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 16:42

Quote:


You need to isolate the pump from the wiring to measure impedance as all you are measuring is the resistance of the wiring if its still connected.




Figured that something wasn't right. Will take the pump out tonight and do a proper measurement.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 16:49

Quote:

but as the pump delivers more flow the voltage will drop as the pump draws more current to do more work.




Is the pump then either on or off? If the power supply is constant then is the pump always trying to deliver the same ammount of fuel? What then determines how much current the pump draws?
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 16:55

Quote:


Im not convinced that voltage will be dropped to the pump on high loads.




Cosmo - if what you'r saying is correct, and this makes sense to me (I was told otherwise). Then the voltage should not drop to the pump under load. Why then do some coops get a voltage drop under load and some not? Is this simply due to crap italian wiring supplying the current?
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 17:17

I think Im confusing you.

What Im saying is that the voltage supplied wont alter but the voltage will still be dropped across the pump due to the current increasing at high loads.

V = I X R. Resistance/ Impedance of the pump and the wiring to it is constant. As current draw increases at high flow conditions the voltage drop across the pump and wiring increases also. Nothing to do with voltage supplied which will remain constant.

The reason some Coops will have voltage drop and some not is both due to:

1/ The health of the pump - A knackered pump will draw more current than a healthy one and

2/ the state of the wiring - dodgy wiring will have more resistance and more voltage drop.


Thinking about it you really need to know the current draw of the Walbro at full load as this will dictate the voltage drop and hence whether you need to upgrade the wiring.

This is my understanding anyway.
Posted By: Begbie

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 18:48

I wouldn't say so much on the wiring causing this, well it is partily the wiring, but its the earthing of the wiring which causes the drop, hence when the relay is fitted, you are earthing in the boot rather than using the wire that trails from the back of the car to the front of the car as an earthing point.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 19:16

Thanks guys. Begbie - did fiat mean to do this, or is it a design flaw?
Posted By: Begbie

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 19:18

*shrugs

I dont work for Fiat so wouldn't have a clue
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 19:23

I'll rephrase - is there any reason why they would earth at the front of the car rather than in the boot?
Posted By: Jimbo

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 20:47

The voltage doesn't drop at the pump when the correct pressure is reached, the fuel pressure regulator just returns the extra fuel to the tank so the fuel rail stays at a constant pressure.

As Begbie said, the crash switch was the problem with the standard fuel pump, it was probably dirty contacts inside the switch causing voltage to be dropped.
Like Cosmo said V= I x R so a more current drawn through the dirty contacts causes a lower voltage at the pump because the voltage drop is being shared through the pump and the resistance of the contacts.

An uprated pump will probably have a higher resistance than the standard pump because it will have more windings on the pump motor hence a higher resistance, thats why the uprated wiring mod should really be done if you fit an uprated fuel pump to cope with the extra current drawn by the pump.

Hope this clears it up slightly Suba ?
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 20:58

off topic...is the fuel pressure regulatore the little shinney thing with spout at the right end of the fuel rail?
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 21:16

Quote:

off topic...is the fuel pressure regulatore the little shinney thing with spout at the right end of the fuel rail?



Yes.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 22:35

Quote:



An uprated pump will probably have a higher resistance than the standard pump because it will have more windings on the pump motor hence a higher resistance, thats why the uprated wiring mod should really be done if you fit an uprated fuel pump to cope with the extra current drawn by the pump.

Hope this clears it up slightly Suba ?




Ok - this is starting to make more sense now - thanks Jim. My theory is exactly that, bigger motor = more current drain - either go for an uprated pump and voltage mod when getting close to 300bhp, or go with the standard pump alone for the above reason. ideally test the voltage + fuelling on an individual car + make the decision from there. I'd like to know how the flow rate of the standard pump and walbro 255 compare using the same original wiring with a voltage drop off - but I doubt this will be much use as it will vary from car to car... But would be nice to have some evidence to back up the theory.

All I know is I ran lean big time using the standard wiring and 255 pump - without having this problem previously, and Highwayman noticed a voltage drop at the pump that was not apparent change the O/E pump for the 255.
Posted By: Jimbo

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 23:40

The only real way to test it is to read the voltage whilst your driving and make sure it doesn't drop below 12v.

I remember Hanny only having 9v at the standard pump and this was probably why his piston melted.

I just pushed 2 bits of wire into the fuel pump plug and extended them to my volt meter on the passenger seat, my voltage was 13v at tick over but dropped to 11v at about 5000rpm when the pump was under load.
This was cured with the fuel pump voltage mod, it read 13.5v all the time.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 21/03/2006 23:48

i couldnt use the meter suba i dont know how to read ohms? what should it read roughly as i had a couple of readings but not sure if i was doing it right or putting on right connections....
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 22/03/2006 00:01

Turn the multimeter to ohm, see sign in the picture.
http://www.pro-ohm.org/online/pic/logo.gif
Posted By: Jimbo

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 22/03/2006 00:59

Meagy,
You will need to unplug the pump from everything else then just put the 2 meter probes on the 2 wires to the pump, that will give you a reading of one set of coils in the pump.

A DC pump uses 3 sets of coils though and an armature to reverse the current through the coils, your reading will vary depending on where the brushes are on the armature.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Walbro 255 pump vs. Standard O/E pump - 22/03/2006 02:32

I just removed mine from the tank and measured. And I still get 0.6-0.7 ohm.
Bear in mind that the multimeter itself gives about 0.3 ohm in the cables/probes.
© 2025 Fiat Coupe Club UK