I don't no if this will help. When I lived in the UK as a young guy, some mates and I all had performance cars and had the same trouble that you are haveing now. We went to an Insurance Broker and he set up what was called a "Block Insurance" for six of us. This allowed us all to drive one anothers cars, and also worked out much cheaper for each of us. For me it meant only haveing to pay 80 pounds as my part of the deal, where if I had taken out the normal Policy, it would have cost me 280 pounds.
Good luck with this, Barry.