|
0 registered members (),
574
guests, and 3
spiders. |
|
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
Forums48
Topics103,776
Posts1,170,742
Members1,683
| |
Most Online39,516 Apr 15th, 2026
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Flea]
#811964
11/04/2009 11:19
11/04/2009 11:19
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387 Staffordshire
Nigel
OP
Forum veteran
|
OP
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387
Staffordshire
|
Thanks for clearing that up Leighton Anyone got any 440s  Jimbo - my MAF was attached directly to the SIP - the filter was on the 45 degree silicon hose I have a horrible feeling that if my MAF was in that state, the inside of the air filter might be as well
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Flea]
#812008
11/04/2009 13:03
11/04/2009 13:03
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
Regarding the injector calculator, for some strange reason what is calculated and what actually works in the 20VT engine are two different results. This calculator works well for every engine except the 20VT  . Anyway I would suggest that at 100% duty and 3.8Bar the cc = max estimated flywheel figure. What actually happens is: 384cc 3.8Bar 100% 370BHP = 0.55 BSFC 330cc 3.8Bar 100% 320BHP = 0.55 BSFC So I would use 0.55 as BSFC for our engines. If Nigel gives some leeway lets say 450BHP target: 450BHP 0.55BSFC 100% 3.8Bar = 463cc Now pull the duty down to a sensible level: 450BHP 0.55BSFC 80% 3.8Bar = 578cc This ties in with what Flea has work out however I would suggest 550cc thus giving you extra leeway should you require more fuel. Consider these: http://www.racetronix.com/INJL48.htmlhttp://www.racetronix.com/01D066x.htmlhttp://www.racetronix.com/3172FM.html
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812033
11/04/2009 14:44
11/04/2009 14:44
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Flea, while i respect your experience with mapping fiat coupes i have to be sceptical here
The type of engine or number of cylinders have very little to do with the amount of fuel needed for a specific amount of power, it is simply the amount of fuel you need to pruduce a given amount of power devided by the number of cylinders
obviously the figures will never be exact and every engine will be slightly different and possibly more effiecent at converting the fuel in to power but never massive amounts better we are talking barely 1% between engines designed from the early 90's to the early 2000's, where the designers have made the biggest jumps in economy are in the fuel injection systems, not the engine itself
I dont think its a good idea to design a fuel system in a turbo charged car around a 0.50 B.S.F.C, it goes against all recomendations
Even if Fiat them selfs look as though they have from the factory designed it with a 0.50 B.S.F.C what in nigels engine is the same as original??, i doubt fiat would have designed this engine to run as rich as 11.5 afr, probably closer to 12.5 if anything(you may be able to clarify this?)
If we used a 0.50 B.S.F.C on the 16vt injectors with a 3.8 bar FPR and 100% duty that would mean that 460bhp would be on the cards!!!
We know thats not true as Jason and Nigel all maxxed out the injectors well before that
Unless you are mapping engines so they are very lean then you cannot be using a 0.50 B.S.F.C, I know your not runing this lean as you have said on numerous occasions that you aim for about 11.5 afr at full load
Nigel, if i were you and you wanted to aim for 450 bhp then the minimum i would go for would be 600cc injectors
That should get you upto 450bhp with a duty of 90%
In all honesty there is no reason why you should not go for the 600cc injectors over the 440's, there will be no detrimental effect to lower speed fueling like some people will tell you, infact if your clever with your choice you may be able to improve it over the 440's as modern injectors are so much better in the last few years
the reason i know this is i used to have some 660's in my skyline and i needed to upgrade them as i was pushing the duty, in the end i went for some 1000cc injectors and the low sped throttle responce actually improved, so did economy slighly when off boost
Ricky
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Flea]
#812034
11/04/2009 14:45
11/04/2009 14:45
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
hello leigton whats the duty set to on my injectors if you can remember mate
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812051
11/04/2009 15:36
11/04/2009 15:36
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
and how did i manage 340bhp on 330cc @ 3bar
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812057
11/04/2009 15:53
11/04/2009 15:53
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
and how did i manage 340bhp on 330cc @ 3bar Even using a 0.50 B.S.F.C and 100% duty you would max out at 310bhp Sorry but you simply could not provide enough fuel for 340bhp, even 310bhp with those injectors would be unlikely What was the WBHP figures?
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812059
11/04/2009 16:04
11/04/2009 16:04
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
293wbhp mate on the famous perfect touch rollers 
Last edited by westcoupe; 11/04/2009 16:07.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812066
11/04/2009 16:17
11/04/2009 16:17
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
sounds like the same sort of problem as nigel had then
Unfortunatly its impossible to get those figures from 330cc injectors
I would put it on someone elses dyno and see what figures you get
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812170
11/04/2009 19:35
11/04/2009 19:35
|
anthrax
Unregistered
|
anthrax
Unregistered
|
Flea, while i respect your experience with mapping fiat coupes i have to be sceptical here
The type of engine or number of cylinders have very little to do with the amount of fuel needed for a specific amount of power, it is simply the amount of fuel you need to pruduce a given amount of power devided by the number of cylinders
obviously the figures will never be exact and every engine will be slightly different and possibly more effiecent at converting the fuel in to power but never massive amounts better we are talking barely 1% between engines designed from the early 90's to the early 2000's, where the designers have made the biggest jumps in economy are in the fuel injection systems, not the engine itself
I dont think its a good idea to design a fuel system in a turbo charged car around a 0.50 B.S.F.C, it goes against all recomendations
Even if Fiat them selfs look as though they have from the factory designed it with a 0.50 B.S.F.C what in nigels engine is the same as original??, i doubt fiat would have designed this engine to run as rich as 11.5 afr, probably closer to 12.5 if anything(you may be able to clarify this?)
If we used a 0.50 B.S.F.C on the 16vt injectors with a 3.8 bar FPR and 100% duty that would mean that 460bhp would be on the cards!!!
We know thats not true as Jason and Nigel all maxxed out the injectors well before that
Unless you are mapping engines so they are very lean then you cannot be using a 0.50 B.S.F.C, I know your not runing this lean as you have said on numerous occasions that you aim for about 11.5 afr at full load
Nigel, if i were you and you wanted to aim for 450 bhp then the minimum i would go for would be 600cc injectors
That should get you upto 450bhp with a duty of 90%
In all honesty there is no reason why you should not go for the 600cc injectors over the 440's, there will be no detrimental effect to lower speed fueling like some people will tell you, infact if your clever with your choice you may be able to improve it over the 440's as modern injectors are so much better in the last few years
the reason i know this is i used to have some 660's in my skyline and i needed to upgrade them as i was pushing the duty, in the end i went for some 1000cc injectors and the low sped throttle responce actually improved, so did economy slighly when off boost
Ricky What modern injectors would you recommend , please? Thanks.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812193
11/04/2009 20:10
11/04/2009 20:10
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
Ricky, the point being made is that the 20VT doesn’t need such high cc injectors. When you reverse the Maths of the formula from what actually happens is you end up with a BSFC of about 0.55. 384cc 3.8Bar 100% 370BHP = 0.55 BSFC The only unknown is the BSFC whether that’s right or not that wants actually happing in the 20VT engine. So for correct sizing of the 20VT engine a BSFC of 0.55 should be used otherwise you end up with huge injectors which are not needed. Theoretically you should have bigger but in reality you don’t. In terms of the mapping side. Too huge will cause problems at idle/cold start and it would more likely effect the Bosch ECU more than a standalone unless Flea has some more tricks in his box  . So it is important for those keeping the Bosch to get the smallest cc yet able to fuel their needs.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812293
11/04/2009 22:19
11/04/2009 22:19
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Its not a good idea to work out the B.S.F.C when the injectors are at 100% duty as at that point the injectors are out of control
We also need to remember that when calculating the difference in flow with an injector at 3 bar and 3.8 bar its only an estimation as unfortunatly the flow increase is not always uniform or linear, sometimes you get more and sometimes you get less, the only way to be sure is to test the individual injectors
Also there is nothing special about the fiat 20vt its not so effiecent that it can use lower cc injectors than any other engine
In your calculations you should always use 0.65 B.S.F.C as thats what is most common, you could go as low as 0.60 but no lower
I can understand that this may be a problem on the bosch ecu but at the end of the day if an engine needs a specific amount of fuel to produce specific amount of power then there are no short cuts, you either make changes to produce the power or you dont produce the power, end of story...
I am not going to go on about this to much more, my advice is as above if people want to take then fine and if not then im not to fussed but please be open and express your findings for the benefit of others
Ricky
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812349
12/04/2009 03:31
12/04/2009 03:31
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
well i aint got 340bhp no more but i am sure i had more then 320+bhp on standard injectors @3bar and if not what bhp would i have been making on a gt28rs at 1.4bar then
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812350
12/04/2009 03:49
12/04/2009 03:49
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
like I said earlier, how did Dfrag, Flea, Squid all get around 360bhp/310whp with standard injectors/fpr??? Methonal Injection can't be that good  I got 325bhp with a very poorly car which was still running 11's AFR and died 2 days later!!!
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812355
12/04/2009 06:37
12/04/2009 06:37
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 5,405 Castle Combe
Flea
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 5,405
Castle Combe
|
Ricky, while I agree with your theoretical standpoint, the bottom line is you can't go against real world data and fact as that is what matters nothing else. You don't need to use a calculator for injector sizing, you just need to use what works. Mark, methanol can increase the AFR considerably if used in sufficent quantities so in some respects in can be considered as a "5th injector". Re the Bosch ecu, well I currently run 600cc injectors with an idle pulswidth of 1.5-1.7ms, giving me stoich  I would suggest that 700cc would be the limit for idle stoich but in terms of having a nice smooth idle and driveability then no reason you couldn't go bigger. The restriction is not the ecu but the actual lag time of the large injectors on a small displacement engine.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#812461
12/04/2009 10:48
12/04/2009 10:48
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
like I said earlier, how did Dfrag, Flea, Squid all get around 360bhp/310whp with standard injectors/fpr??? Methonal Injection can't be that good  I got 325bhp with a very poorly car which was still running 11's AFR and died 2 days later!!! eldinho i think your looking at it the wrong way For some reason you and many other users on this forum take the flywheel figures that you have been given as gospel Technincally its impossible to make some of the figures being quoted but rather than question the figures people automatically presume that the the fiat 20vt engine is something special and what ever dyno they have been on is 100% accurate, the 20vt engine is NOT so advanced that its more fuel effiecent than all other turbo charged engines, its run of the mill stuff I understand that its hard being told that the power you beleive your car is making is unrealistic but all my calculations above are done using realistic figures TBH it makes no difference to anyone, why run injectors beyond the safe limit and in some cases at 100% duty??? Why not run with a safty margin? at least running larger injectors you know they will not be the limiting factor and at a later date you can decide to push the setup further and you wont have to fork out for injectors again Anyway its down to your selfs to decide what way you go but beleive me im only trying to help here and i know how disapointing it can be to not hit the figures your were expecting Good luck, what ever way you guys decide go Ricky
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Nigel]
#812582
12/04/2009 16:14
12/04/2009 16:14
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813533
14/04/2009 12:41
14/04/2009 12:41
|
MiniPit
Unregistered
|
MiniPit
Unregistered
|
Jari is running 440cc injectors on a 400HP+ coop too  When i was searching for my future injectors i had a discussion with him. He said that Bosch Giant Green 440cc were the good choice. Same split pattern as OE injectors and no problem with the AFR running 410HP (with 3.8 bar FPR)  The "injector calculator" told us 440cc won't be able to fuel enough on a 400HP+ 20VT... but in reality lots of coops are running 440cc and 400HP+  Can we view our engines as the exception?
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813597
14/04/2009 14:33
14/04/2009 14:33
|
nyssa7
Unregistered
|
nyssa7
Unregistered
|
Seems to be something strange with the 20vt - Owens told me my fuel pump couldn't deliver the fuel for more than 500bhp, the most they had seen on any Mitsu Evo using the same pump was 495bhp. So imagine my surprise when they recorded 587bhp with the kappa 20vt - and they were just as surprised
Now only using that pump as a lifter, fitted a swirl pot and heavy duty Bosch number under the bonnet in preparation for the 2.4s appetite for fuel
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813611
14/04/2009 14:52
14/04/2009 14:52
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
He said that Bosch Giant Green 440cc were the good choice. Same split pattern as OE injectors and no problem with the AFR running 410HP (with 3.8 bar FPR)  The 440cc Bosch are very dated, the spray pattern is not a proper split and is designed for single intake valve per cylinder. You should be looking at the Genesis which go up to 550cc then the Siemens are good for more fuel. Look at the spray patterns here: http://www.usrallyteam.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=10_44
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813620
14/04/2009 15:12
14/04/2009 15:12
|
MiniPit
Unregistered
|
MiniPit
Unregistered
|
The 440cc Bosch are very dated, the spray pattern is not a proper split and is designed for single intake valve per cylinder. You should be looking at the Genesis which go up to 550cc then the Siemens are good for more fuel. Look at the spray patterns here: http://www.usrallyteam.com/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=10_44 Yes J you're right. But i'm not talking about Bosch 440 Green like you can see on usrallyteam. I speak about the Giant green version. Green have a wide single spray and big green a dual spray with 15° angle like OE ones. Jari have compared these 2 types of "green" and told me not to buy the "classic" green version. That's why i was interested in "Giant" version Do you agree?
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813658
14/04/2009 16:10
14/04/2009 16:10
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
I would agree if they meet the requirements for a multi valve cylinder head. If you are sure that they do then go for them.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813702
14/04/2009 17:21
14/04/2009 17:21
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Seems to be something strange with the 20vt - Owens told me my fuel pump couldn't deliver the fuel for more than 500bhp, the most they had seen on any Mitsu Evo using the same pump was 495bhp. So imagine my surprise when they recorded 587bhp with the kappa 20vt - and they were just as surprised
Now only using that pump as a lifter, fitted a swirl pot and heavy duty Bosch number under the bonnet in preparation for the 2.4s appetite for fuel Was that with a walbro pump?? if so i have had nearly 600bhp with the same pump in a friends skyline before it started to run out of guts, it even out flowed a nismo pump, in the end he used the walbro as a lift pump and then from a swirl pot he used two bosch 044's running into either end of the fuel rail with a centre return A bit overkill but he now has enough fuel for 1000bhp Ricky
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813844
14/04/2009 19:36
14/04/2009 19:36
|
JohnS
Unregistered
|
JohnS
Unregistered
|
I don't think it is beyond the realm of possibility that Nigel's car did make 400BHP at some point. There are a ton of little bits and pieces that might make a difference.
For instance, you mentioned oil in the MAF - imagine ho much oil is probably in your intercooler. The oil itself will act to reduce the effective RON of the fuel. It will still be all over your inlet. Anything like a tiny chip on your compressor wheel could cause that sort of change in power.
I don't think you should upgrade turbo as it will make the car less driveable, which is why I have ended up with a GT3082R hybrid instead of the GT3582R I briefly had fitted. Unless you are just after headline power it isn't worth it, the area under the power graph is more important for everyday motors.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#813897
14/04/2009 20:26
14/04/2009 20:26
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387 Staffordshire
Nigel
OP
Forum veteran
|
OP
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387
Staffordshire
|
Thanks for the words of encouragement John
The car is in at Motormech tomorrow for an MOT (almost forgot again!) and also to investigate the oil in the inlet.
The current diagnosis is a simple one - oil return from the recirc cannister is blocked AND the non-return valve from the plenum to the cannister is fubar'd. this means that on boost, I'm pressurising the oil recirc cannister to whatever boost I'm running.
The above diagnosis is far easier on my heart and my wallet than worn rings causing blow-by and a pressurised crankcase
I also have a decent sized oil leak, coming (we think) from the oil filter area, so again, this would point to a pressurised crankcase.
John - like you say, an inlet charge heavy with oil mist is going to play havoc with my octane rating and would also go a long way to explaining why Leighton couldn't get my car to respond to ignition advance.
Once the issue is diagnosed, I will remove the entire inlet tract and clean it out. I just hope the turbo is relatively clean inside, as I don't fancy blasting that with carb cleaner. Hopefully, the air velocity will have kept it clean.
Last time I had the intercooler off, I used a full spray can of carb cleaner to get the oil out of it.
fingers crossed that its something simple (and cheap)
BTW - it looks like I'm going to settle for Bosch Giant Green injectors - 440s, which is closer to 500 with a 3.8 bar FPR. This should be plenty to give over 400bhp AND will give Leighton a fighting chance of keeping it drivable at small throttle openings
|
|
|
|