Fiat Coupe Forum
- Funded by the Club for the benefit of all owners
- Please consider joining the Club to help keep the Forum running
- Or you can choose to make a Donation
Fiat Coupe Club UK
join the club
Fiat Coupe Forum
 
» Club Members only
    Workshop manual


» Announced
    Posting images


» Related sites
    Main club site
    fiatcoupe.net

 
Who's Online Now
1 registered members (Edinburgh), 399 guests, and 2 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Forums48
Topics103,776
Posts1,170,742
Members1,683
Most Online39,516
Apr 15th, 2026
Top Posters(All Time)
barnacle 33,794
stan 32,123
Theresa 23,350
PeteP 22,315
bockers 21,083
Edinburgh 19,117
JimO 17,919
Nigel 17,387
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2
20vt crank/rods vs 20na #1173137
18/02/2011 14:53
18/02/2011 14:53

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



Can anyone confirm whether the stroke of the 20vt and 20na crank are the same and whether the length of the rods are also?

From what I gather, the only difference between the two engines (internally) is that the crank/rods are stronger and the pistons are dished on the 20vt to achieve lower CR.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173143
18/02/2011 15:01
18/02/2011 15:01
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,208
Sofia,Bulgaria
kaci Offline
My job on the forum
kaci  Offline
My job on the forum

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,208
Sofia,Bulgaria
Crankshaft is the same for both engines. Rods are not!


[Linked Image]
Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: kaci] #1173151
18/02/2011 15:12
18/02/2011 15:12

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



Don't suppose you know how different the rods are? Is it just length? I take it they are shorter?

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173160
18/02/2011 15:37
18/02/2011 15:37
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,208
Sofia,Bulgaria
kaci Offline
My job on the forum
kaci  Offline
My job on the forum

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,208
Sofia,Bulgaria
click to enlarge


[Linked Image]
Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: kaci] #1173161
18/02/2011 15:43
18/02/2011 15:43

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



Thank you! laugh

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173217
18/02/2011 17:58
18/02/2011 17:58

1
1NRO
Unregistered
1NRO
Unregistered
1



Doesn't matter if your geting custom pistons, measure the block you'll be using and get the piston to head clearance correct with your custom rod, this is the way to do it IMO

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173244
18/02/2011 19:34
18/02/2011 19:34

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



it does if they have a custom compression height wink that way off the shelf rods can be used. rods are more expensive than pistons generally.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173248
18/02/2011 19:50
18/02/2011 19:50

1
1NRO
Unregistered
1NRO
Unregistered
1



I thought you were building a high level engine? To compromise the piston design to suit an off the shelf rod doesn't add up to me. Design pistons and then connect to crank with a suitable rod, piston comes first.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173306
18/02/2011 22:30
18/02/2011 22:30

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



well, i'm looking at the big picture - if people can use off the shelf bits they'll be more likely to use the engine in competition then eventually, custom stuff will come down in price.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173311
18/02/2011 22:36
18/02/2011 22:36

1
1NRO
Unregistered
1NRO
Unregistered
1



The levels you talk about and the budget/method you refer to are miles apart, sorry but that is the reality.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173318
18/02/2011 22:51
18/02/2011 22:51

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



well, we'll see won't we.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173320
18/02/2011 22:54
18/02/2011 22:54

1
1NRO
Unregistered
1NRO
Unregistered
1



Start saving :-)

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1173424
19/02/2011 09:00
19/02/2011 09:00
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,208
Sofia,Bulgaria
kaci Offline
My job on the forum
kaci  Offline
My job on the forum

Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,208
Sofia,Bulgaria
Here is a picture that visually see the difference!
click to enlarge


[Linked Image]
Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: kaci] #1173520
19/02/2011 14:11
19/02/2011 14:11

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



cheers mate laugh

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174099
20/02/2011 19:44
20/02/2011 19:44

T
TurboJ
Unregistered
TurboJ
Unregistered
T



Originally Posted by nedge2k
well, i'm looking at the big picture - if people can use off the shelf bits they'll be more likely to use the engine in competition then eventually, custom stuff will come down in price.


Not sure if that makes any sense to me.

Depends how you define competition. All competition stuff I know of is custom. I doubt any engine builder will ever buy off the shelf components for competition use.

Custom stuff will never come down in price because it is custom. One off parts cost money.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174186
20/02/2011 22:49
20/02/2011 22:49

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



i'm talking clubman motorsport - rally, sprint, hill climb, autograss etc. - plenty of builders buy off the shelf stuff for that. when off the shelf becomes not enough, custom stuff gets made. the companies who make the stuff then sell it to other people, the price comes down and it becomes the new "off the shelf" stuff.

Last edited by nedge2k; 20/02/2011 22:52.
Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174289
21/02/2011 09:48
21/02/2011 09:48

1
1NRO
Unregistered
1NRO
Unregistered
1



I think you'll find if you progress to custom stuff it won't end up as mainstream, when you go to the trouble of specifying and designing items they are your intellectual property which a decent manufacturer will respect.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174426
21/02/2011 13:22
21/02/2011 13:22

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



True but it also depends on whether you are going direct to the manufacturer with the design or via a supplier/builder and asking for it to be designed.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174525
21/02/2011 17:49
21/02/2011 17:49

G
group5lancia
Unregistered
group5lancia
Unregistered
G



If you want to keep production rods the engine will not be able to rev as high as you have mentioned previously.

I've looked up data on some engines that you might want to match or beat as a 'modified production engine' spec rather than an all-out racing spec. Below are the outputs you should expect if you can get the same volumetric efficiency:

BMW M3 (S54B32 engine) BMEP 11.64 BAR - 208 BHP @ 7900 rpm
Honda S2000 BMEP 12.60 BAR - 225 BHP @ 7900 rpm
Porsche GT3 RS BMEP 13.07 BAR - 234 BHP @ 7900 rpm

I'm sure that getting output up from 117 BHP/litre to 150 BHP/litre will require a lot of bespoke parts and therefore be expensive. Have a look at the SBD website to see what was required to get a Duratec 2 litre to 300 BHP at 8800 rpm.

Last edited by group5lancia; 21/02/2011 17:51.
Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174531
21/02/2011 17:56
21/02/2011 17:56

1
1NRO
Unregistered
1NRO
Unregistered
1



Originally Posted by nedge2k
True but it also depends on whether you are going direct to the manufacturer with the design or via a supplier/builder and asking for it to be designed.


You'd have to be commissioning a parts whore to do the design for it to become mainstream and this is the not the kind of person to be asking for the kind of parts you need.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174532
21/02/2011 18:02
21/02/2011 18:02

G
group5lancia
Unregistered
group5lancia
Unregistered
G



Originally Posted by TurboJ
Depends how you define competition. All competition stuff I know of is custom. I doubt any engine builder will ever buy off the shelf components for competition use.

Custom stuff will never come down in price because it is custom. One off parts cost money.


Not strictly true, I would argue. With engines commonly used in competition there are a load of 'specialist' parts which are pretty common - simply because of the quantity of engines that have been built. For example, visit Burton's website and you will find a tonne of stuff to uprate a Ford, Lotus or Cosworth engine. And people like Arrow rods have Ford/Cosworth rods in their cataloge as 'off the peg' items. The Vauxhall XE, K series, Zetec and more recently the Duratec are also pretty well served. Jenvey offer cast inlet manifolds for their throttle bodies for the most popular engines - they wouldn't make patterns and have castings produced if there wasn't a decent market for them.

Being a trail-blazer with the five pot Fiat engine will not be so easy, of course, and lots of parts will have to be fabricated or machined as one-offs.

Last edited by group5lancia; 21/02/2011 18:06.
Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174545
21/02/2011 18:30
21/02/2011 18:30

S
sediciRich
Unregistered
sediciRich
Unregistered
S



Slightly off topic; I think the popularity of a certain unit also bases upon its availablity and very much on its compatibility especially with common gearboxes - namely the RWD types like the ubiquitous type 9 pattern.

Vauxhall XE, Cosworth YB, K Series had been used in so many models over such a period (excluding the YB but its was used for what apprx 15 yrs in the road going cosworths). How are fiat units not as popular as Opel's XE, must be quantity produced, popularity of the original vehicle (esp with regards to factory motorsport) and the compatibilty with bellhousings. I believe it was the balancer block on the 16v which made rwd conversion very difficult (even the F3 version didnt use a balancer block) and lost the popularity the 8v versions had in non F/L applications. Never mind we are but a minority.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174634
21/02/2011 21:18
21/02/2011 21:18

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



I did try to subtlety mention this in the other thread but I work for an engine specialist, one who caters to some of the engines mentioned here and competes directly with some of the companies mentioned here hence why my take on things is a little different to some of you. I do know exactly what is required to get it anywhere near 300bhp but I also know that stupid money doesn't always have to be spent to get decent gains - especially when you're doing an interesting project like this and can ask the odd favour...

I'm not saying it'll be able to rev to 10k with turbo rods and arp bolts but 8k will do for now.

Last edited by nedge2k; 21/02/2011 21:22.
Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174711
21/02/2011 22:41
21/02/2011 22:41

1
1NRO
Unregistered
1NRO
Unregistered
1




He really is an expert if he can get to 300 bhp out of the Fiat 20v engine all motor even if the budget was massive, I'd advise you to find the relevent sums and see for yourself rather than take someone elses word for it. Don't believe the hype!

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1174734
21/02/2011 23:07
21/02/2011 23:07

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



Sigh.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1326316
19/03/2012 09:00
19/03/2012 09:00

T
th130
Unregistered
th130
Unregistered
T



So how did you get on nedge?

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1335952
18/04/2012 21:12
18/04/2012 21:12

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



well, i can see the light at the end of the tunnel, put it that way!

the std rods would have been fine for around 8.5k with arp bolts (i know of c20xe engines like this that have lasted over 3 seasons with no issues - and their std rods aren't as meaty!!) but the 20v n/a rod bolts are longer than anything arp do with that thread and custom bolts would have cost more than custom rods - so i went with custom rods and while i was at it, due to the lack of a decent end bearing for the n/a (or the turbo), i had the rods made to take an oversize race bearing from another engine which required 0.001" ground off the crank.

plenty of other odds and sods to finish off but the last thing really holding everything up now is the exhaust manifold - which i've put off for as long as possible as if it's wrong, i could easily loose 30bhp and with manifolds costing around a grand at a time, it needs to be right, first time!

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1335980
18/04/2012 23:19
18/04/2012 23:19

T
tricky
Unregistered
tricky
Unregistered
T



So what are you going to do to make sure it is right ?

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1336043
19/04/2012 09:23
19/04/2012 09:23

N
nedge2k
Unregistered
nedge2k
Unregistered
N



well, for a start there are dozens of formulas for working it out and various bits of software so i'll try them all against know engine spec / manifold combinations and when i find the closest, knock up a set of adjustable dyno pipes to fine tune it all.

Re: 20vt crank/rods vs 20na [Re: ] #1336288
19/04/2012 22:21
19/04/2012 22:21

T
TurboJ
Unregistered
TurboJ
Unregistered
T



I use GT power.

Page 1 of 2 1 2

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1
(Release build 20190129)
PHP: 7.4.33 Page Time: 0.019s Queries: 15 (0.011s) Memory: 0.7044 MB (Peak: 0.9161 MB) Data Comp: Off Server Time: 2026-11-19 14:20:57 UTC