4 registered members (Gryka, Rob40, Rosso, CVL200),
142
guests, and 3
spiders. |
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
Forums69
Topics113,609
Posts1,341,214
Members1,802
|
Most Online731 Jan 14th, 2020
|
|
|
Another proud moment for Human Rights...
#1307165
17/01/2012 12:28
17/01/2012 12:28
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307201
17/01/2012 13:52
17/01/2012 13:52
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731 Surrey
Emjay
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731
Surrey
|
From the link:
Allowing a criminal court to rely on torture evidence would legitimise the torture of witnesses and suspects pre-trial. Moreover, torture evidence was unreliable, because a person being tortured would say anything to make it stop.
The Court found that torture was widespread in Jordan, as was the use of torture evidence by the Jordanian courts.
The Court also found that, in relation to each of the two terrorist conspiracies charged against Mr Othman, the evidence of his involvement had been obtained by torturing one of his co-defendants.
Strasbourg said that it was highly probable that the "decisive" evidence against the preacher had come from abusing these defendants.
In the absence of any assurance by Jordan that the torture evidence would not be used against Mr Othman, the Court therefore concluded that his deportation to Jordan to be retried would give rise to a flagrant denial of justice in violation of his right to a fair trial
So the basic problem is that Jordan would not give any assurance that evidence obtained by torture would not be used.
Closer scrutiny means that it would make no sense if you are the sort of person would have no qualms about being put personally on trial (and not within the English legal system) on the basis of evidence given by someone in another country who was being tortured. That doesn't work for me - but I have no problem with him being put on trial and having to give an account.
Does our law condemn a man without first hearing him to find out what he has been doing? (John 7:51)
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307236
17/01/2012 15:49
17/01/2012 15:49
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,567 Northampton England
Sedicivalvole
Club member 2092
|
Club member 2092
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,567
Northampton England
|
That is a good judgement imo.
British Judges always seem to make stupid decisions in these cases.
You cannot send him back to Jordan to stand trial when the evidence used against him is from torture. Whats the point. You might as well shoot him here and save everyone the bother.
Why the British Judges think it is acceptable to send him their in the first place is what is wrong.
Also a diplomatic agreement is not in my own opinion a suitable safety guarantee.
Granted he is not a nice guy it seems, but descending to torture, bodged justice or condoning it makes us not far off what we accuse him of being.
British Justice is not what it once was.
Vinci Grey LE Alfa 147 GTA 3.2 V6 BMW E92 M3 4.0 V8 Fiat Tipo Sedicivalvole 2.0 16v ABS
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Sedicivalvole]
#1307271
17/01/2012 17:12
17/01/2012 17:12
|
doug20vt
Unregistered
|
doug20vt
Unregistered
|
bugger being politically correct, this guy is heavily involved in international terrorist activites encouraging the killing of innocent civilians
he contributes nothing to Britain at all and all he and his family do is cost us a fortune, deport him and sod the European Court of Human rights, whatever happens to him happens
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Sedicivalvole]
#1307274
17/01/2012 17:20
17/01/2012 17:20
|
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,748 Pistonheads
Brewster
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,748
Pistonheads
|
If the ECHR don't want him to go to Jordan then maybe we should stick him and his family on the next ferry out of Hull and they can look after this poor, downtrodden mite. Or better still; You might as well shoot him here and save everyone the bother. Bullets are a lot cheaper than an overnight crossing.
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307276
17/01/2012 17:22
17/01/2012 17:22
|
tim42
Unregistered
|
tim42
Unregistered
|
Send him on a Mediterranean cruise
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307277
17/01/2012 17:26
17/01/2012 17:26
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731 Surrey
Emjay
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731
Surrey
|
bugger being politically correct, this guy is heavily involved in international terrorist activites encouraging the killing of innocent civilians Then he can be tried for that. Nobody is saying he can't and should not be tried for that. What does that have to do with the appropriateness of relying upon evidence obtained by torture? If not allowing evidence obtained by torture is your idea of 'politically correct' that might be over-egging the pudding.
Does our law condemn a man without first hearing him to find out what he has been doing? (John 7:51)
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Brewster]
#1307280
17/01/2012 17:31
17/01/2012 17:31
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731 Surrey
Emjay
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731
Surrey
|
If the ECHR don't want him to go to Jordan The ECHR don't want him to be tried on the basis of evidence obtained by torture. If Jordan say they won't be using evidence obtained by torture he is on the next boat. I'm not sure there is really anything in that decision for anyone to get worked up about.
Does our law condemn a man without first hearing him to find out what he has been doing? (John 7:51)
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Emjay]
#1307301
17/01/2012 18:07
17/01/2012 18:07
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,567 Northampton England
Sedicivalvole
Club member 2092
|
Club member 2092
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,567
Northampton England
|
bugger being politically correct, this guy is heavily involved in international terrorist activites encouraging the killing of innocent civilians Then he can be tried for that. Nobody is saying he can't and should not be tried for that. What does that have to do with the appropriateness of relying upon evidence obtained by torture? If not allowing evidence obtained by torture is your idea of 'politically correct' that might be over-egging the pudding. Sorry but I think Emjay is on the money here.
Vinci Grey LE Alfa 147 GTA 3.2 V6 BMW E92 M3 4.0 V8 Fiat Tipo Sedicivalvole 2.0 16v ABS
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Sedicivalvole]
#1307313
17/01/2012 18:29
17/01/2012 18:29
|
doug20vt
Unregistered
|
doug20vt
Unregistered
|
i'm sorry but this guy wouldn't think twice about killing any of us or our families or supporting organisations that would do and would rejoice were any of us to meet our demise in such an unfortunate way
i frankly couldn't care less about folk like that and I want them out of our country, if Jordan have tortured him, then frankly good for them, sorry if that's not politically correct but when dealing with dangerous lunatics like him doing it the 'right way' just doesn't work
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Brewster]
#1307317
17/01/2012 18:36
17/01/2012 18:36
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 12,546 Northumberland
AndrewR
I AM a Coop
|
I AM a Coop
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 12,546
Northumberland
|
there comes a point where morals should take precedent. Nice to see you in agreement for once, Brewster.
Dear monos, a secret truth.
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: AndrewR]
#1307319
17/01/2012 18:41
17/01/2012 18:41
|
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 6,144 Southampton, Hants
Roadking
Club member 1809
|
Club member 1809
Forum is my life
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 6,144
Southampton, Hants
|
there comes a point where morals should take precedent. Nice to see you in agreement for once, Brewster. Who decides the morals? My moral code has no problem with the idea of him just disappearing one night, never to be seen again. I could think of some other names to add to the list as well.
"RK's way seems the most sensible to me". ali_hire 16 Dec 2010
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: samsite999]
#1307320
17/01/2012 18:43
17/01/2012 18:43
|
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 6,144 Southampton, Hants
Roadking
Club member 1809
|
Club member 1809
Forum is my life
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 6,144
Southampton, Hants
|
If you are really after a misscarage of justice look towards the USA extraditing a UK citizen for something that isn't even a crime here. The case you're referring to Sam?
"RK's way seems the most sensible to me". ali_hire 16 Dec 2010
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307331
17/01/2012 19:11
17/01/2012 19:11
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 16,603 Corridor of Uncertainty
Jim_Clennell
Forum veteran
|
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 16,603
Corridor of Uncertainty
|
If we are all agreed that he is a very bad man indeed, then why not try him in a UK court on charges of being very bad. If we don't have enough evidence and the only place that does, has based this on things said by someone whose testicles are on fire, then I doubt it's very reliable. You really wouldn't believe the appalling things I'd admit to if I was even threatened with being tortured. All this judgement says is that if it's not ok to convict someone here using dodgy evidence, then there's a tiny inconsistency with sending them somewhere where the authorities have refused to deny that they will do just that. If the usual Lords of Swift and Implacable Justice will step away from the mouth froth, they will see that really, this decision is pretty inevitable. Sorry if that's less satisfying than an iron coffin with spikes on the inside as Monty Python once said, but hey, civilisation, what a bummer.
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307335
17/01/2012 19:26
17/01/2012 19:26
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731 Surrey
Emjay
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 6,731
Surrey
|
Do you honestly believe that what the ECHR has done here is based on morality? I do think the admissibility of evidence obtained by torture is a moral question, but not exclusively so. The court is a legal forum, not a moral one. That does not mean that moral decisions don't influence the development and formation of law. Do you think the lawyer that has won this case will go home to his big, tax-payer funded mansion and feel a warm glow that he has done the right thing? Yes. As well as discharging their professional duty to their client, it looks to have been a good decision bearing in mind the court conclusion on the facts (inconvenient as they may be to a good bilious rant). What has happened is some clever dick laywer(s) have seen a way of putting in yet another big bill to the EU whilst getting many slaps on the back from all the other honourable defenders of justice hovering around that trough for sticking two fingers up to the UK Govt. I'm not sure this really is some lawyer trying to circumvent due process by the old 'torture' loophole. The courts conclusions on the facts made the decision inevitable. If anyone thinks this case was anything more than a lawyer making a name for himself and earning a new wing to the mansion they are very misguided. Or, just perhaps, you could be going off on one (entertaining as it may be) without having really understood and balanced the arguments?
Does our law condemn a man without first hearing him to find out what he has been doing? (John 7:51)
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307344
17/01/2012 19:52
17/01/2012 19:52
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 33,561 Berlin
barnacle
Club Member 18 - ex-Minister without Portfolio
|
Club Member 18 - ex-Minister without Portfolio
Forum Demigod
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 33,561
Berlin
|
i'm sorry but this guy wouldn't think twice about killing any of us or our families or supporting organisations that would do and would rejoice were any of us to meet our demise in such an unfortunate way And that is *exactly* why we should be punctilious in our application of legal justice to him, lest we descend to his level.
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Emjay]
#1307345
17/01/2012 19:58
17/01/2012 19:58
|
doug20vt
Unregistered
|
doug20vt
Unregistered
|
this is a guy who utterly despises our infidel way of life and who will actively seek to recruit other lunatics into organisations who seek to actively harm individuals in both our country and abroad, yet at the same time taking full advantage of the benefits systems and the legal protection afforded by our state
this softly softly approach taken by certain individuals within our country and backed up by the ECHR will make this country a haven for lunatics like this and while its all very well to take the moral high ground and say the individuals rights should be protected surely it is more important to protect the rights of the overwhelming majority of decent law abiding citizen rather then the vile minority of those terrorists who come in to this country
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307347
17/01/2012 20:15
17/01/2012 20:15
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 16,603 Corridor of Uncertainty
Jim_Clennell
Forum veteran
|
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 16,603
Corridor of Uncertainty
|
this is a guy who utterly despises our infidel way of life and who will actively seek to recruit other lunatics into organisations who seek to actively harm individuals in both our country and abroad, yet at the same time taking full advantage of the benefits systems and the legal protection afforded by our state
this softly softly approach taken by certain individuals within our country and backed up by the ECHR will make this country a haven for lunatics like this and while its all very well to take the moral high ground and say the individuals rights should be protected surely it is more important to protect the rights of the overwhelming majority of decent law abiding citizen rather then the vile minority of those terrorists who come in to this country So what action are you advocating and based on what evidence?
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Emjay]
#1307349
17/01/2012 20:42
17/01/2012 20:42
|
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,748 Pistonheads
Brewster
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 5,748
Pistonheads
|
Or, just perhaps, you could be going off on one (entertaining as it may be) without having really understood and balanced the arguments? Oh no, I understand exactly what your/their argument is. Doesn't mean I like it. So what action are you advocating and based on what evidence? If I was High Chancellor I'd arrange a live television broadcast addressed to the ECHR where I kicked the defendant off the white cliffs of Dover, based on the fact that he is an odious man advocating terrorism in a country that is stupid enough to defend his right to do so. Looking down the camera I'd then ask them what they'd like to do about it while I flagged the vees and an orchestra played some rousing Elgar in the background. Unfortunately for everyone, bar muslim extremists, I am not.
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307351
17/01/2012 20:43
17/01/2012 20:43
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
this is a guy who utterly despises our infidel way of life and who will actively seek to recruit other lunatics into organisations who seek to actively harm individuals in both our country and abroad, yet at the same time taking full advantage of the benefits systems and the legal protection afforded by our state
this softly softly approach taken by certain individuals within our country and backed up by the ECHR will make has made this country a haven for lunatics like this and while its all very well to take the moral high ground and say the individuals rights should be protected surely it is more important to protect the rights of the overwhelming majority of decent law abiding citizen rather then the vile minority of those terrorists who come in to this country
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307353
17/01/2012 20:45
17/01/2012 20:45
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: Brewster]
#1307355
17/01/2012 20:47
17/01/2012 20:47
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 16,603 Corridor of Uncertainty
Jim_Clennell
Forum veteran
|
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 16,603
Corridor of Uncertainty
|
So what action are you advocating and based on what evidence? If I was High Chancellor I'd arrange a live television broadcast addressed to the ECHR where I kicked the defendant off the white cliffs of Dover, based on the fact that he is an odious man advocating terrorism in a country that is stupid enough to defend his right to do so. Looking down the camera I'd then ask them what they'd like to do about it while I flagged the vees and an orchestra played some rousing Elgar in the background. Unfortunately for everyone, bar muslim extremists, I am not. Oh I see. Well, why didn't you say so? For a moment I thought you might consider something deranged that could undermine your argument.
|
|
|
Re: Another proud moment for Human Rights...
[Re: ]
#1307357
17/01/2012 20:48
17/01/2012 20:48
|
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,927 The Faringdon Folly
oxfordSteve
Forum is my job
|
Forum is my job
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,927
The Faringdon Folly
|
Are you sure?
I thought he was held in Belmarsh without charge or trial, before being released when the bleeding heart liberals pointed out that such a course of action was illegal.
Last edited by oxfordSteve; 17/01/2012 20:51.
|
|
|
|