So far I've managed without a Quaife. Afterall a good suspension setup with an NA engine has been ok without a Quaife.
I only use 15" rims and the common tires are around 195/50 or 205/50. Smaller rims won't fit and thinner tires are hard to come by. I mostly buy used tires from competitive racers, so the size choices are limited by regulations.
Most of the time I'm on third, some slow corners on second, and the fourth gear only on the main straights. On second I suffer somewhat from wheelspin and the gear runs out very fast. With a lower third, I could use that, fourth and even fifth.
I'm also upgrading the engine from 2,0 to 2,4, so the extra torque will help. That is why I feel that I could certainly benefit from shorter gearing. Afterall its just a track day toy, so top speed is irrelevant.
Edit: here you see the track:
Youtube There is a cool down lap at the beginning. The fast one was 1:42.7 driven at my friends bachelor party. My record stands now at 1:38.55