1 registered members (1 invisible),
150
guests, and 2
spiders. |
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
Forums69
Topics113,608
Posts1,341,198
Members1,802
|
Most Online731 Jan 14th, 2020
|
|
|
Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
#580828
04/04/2008 03:54
04/04/2008 03:54
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
Would like to compile some info on why engines have failed.
Preferable 20vt engines under tune.
What power was it running? What let go? Why did it let go?
Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580850
04/04/2008 04:20
04/04/2008 04:20
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
you probably already know mine
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580858
04/04/2008 04:28
04/04/2008 04:28
|
Nobby
Unregistered
|
Nobby
Unregistered
|
There was a thread like this a while ago - think it was started by Bockers
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580859
04/04/2008 04:28
04/04/2008 04:28
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
I dont know the final reason. I remember u said 3 pistons were down on compression. What was the final diagnosis?
Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580860
04/04/2008 04:29
04/04/2008 04:29
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
There was a thread like this a while ago - think it was started by Bockers Oo oo. That would be good. Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580866
04/04/2008 04:34
04/04/2008 04:34
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
the pistons cracked around the ringlands, think it was down to too much heat, thats what Accralite said anyway! are you getting worried already Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580869
04/04/2008 04:36
04/04/2008 04:36
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
the pistons cracked around the ringlands, think it was down to too much heat, thats what Accralite said anyway! are you getting worried already Ross Well.... Im just wondering. Supposedly running a turbo outside its efficiency creates LOTS of heat. So technically running a bigger turbo within its efficiencies is gonna produce less heat and hence more power for safer. But i know that the engine might still let go. If it does, its off the road and forged. But just wanna see what else i need to watch for. Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580878
04/04/2008 04:43
04/04/2008 04:43
|
Gralecoupe
Unregistered
|
Gralecoupe
Unregistered
|
If your worried about that then check your inlet temps, if your cooler is good enough it will bring them down enough for the engine to be happy.
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580879
04/04/2008 04:45
04/04/2008 04:45
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
If your worried about that then check your inlet temps, if your cooler is good enough it will bring them down enough for the engine to be happy. What should i hope for them to be at? I have fitted Aquamist to combat the heat aswell. As far as i know this will buy me some needed safety. Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580944
04/04/2008 12:51
04/04/2008 12:51
|
sparco
Unregistered
|
sparco
Unregistered
|
Did you break down the other day? Somebody said they seen a yellow coupe at the side of the road which was stripped out inside.
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: JohnS]
#580973
04/04/2008 13:40
04/04/2008 13:40
|
Squid
Unregistered
|
Squid
Unregistered
|
I totally agree with John. My car was running 350bhp with standard internals. When Eldhino's engine went, I realised that I then had the most powerfull coupe with standard internals, so I had it all checked.
Guess what I found? The ringlands had gone on one of the pistons. So, I bought forged internals and had the engine rebuilt. I was running with a pro alloy intercooler and Aquamist with 50/50 water methanol, and my inlet temps were good.
I had been running with that power for little over a year, but had only done 8k miles. So, anyone running over 300bhp should start saving for forged internals, because IMO it WILL go bang eventually.
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580975
04/04/2008 13:44
04/04/2008 13:44
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
Well i've been running over 300bhp for 15k miles. 310-320 for the first 8-9k and 330bhp+ since then.
But what turbo were u running squid?
Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580977
04/04/2008 13:46
04/04/2008 13:46
|
Squid
Unregistered
|
Squid
Unregistered
|
GT28RS - 325bhp at the wheels, which is over 350bhp at the fly on most dynos and 320lbs of torque.
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#580979
04/04/2008 13:51
04/04/2008 13:51
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
GT28RS - 325bhp at the wheels, which is over 350bhp at the fly on most dynos and 320lbs of torque. What boost were u running? Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#581093
04/04/2008 15:38
04/04/2008 15:38
|
Nobby
Unregistered
|
Nobby
Unregistered
|
Here it is. Probably needs expanding a little concerning tolerances of standard internals etc...
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#581108
04/04/2008 15:54
04/04/2008 15:54
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
h2ypr
Unregistered
|
Here it is. Probably needs expanding a little concerning tolerances of standard internals etc... Agreed. Maybe an idea for JohnS to add a section? Ross
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#581115
04/04/2008 16:10
04/04/2008 16:10
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
hello squid you told me you had done under 3k on the turbo that i bought off of you well if not that will explain why
my seals are going already and mine as only just been mapped 4 weeks ago
Last edited by westcoupe; 04/04/2008 16:11.
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#581124
04/04/2008 16:27
04/04/2008 16:27
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
There has been an open discussion about stock pistons vs. forged pistons on a Danish tuning forum, but the conclussion was that stock pistons from a turbo engine should hold up to the same power as forged pistons - only thing forged pistons can do is take alot more detonation and lean mixture, because of the heat tolerance. I know there is an issue with the 20vt pistons cracking at the ring lands, but i believe it's a matter of correct tuning. Monitoring EGT, AFR and listening for detonation, backpressure etc. Jari has been making ALOT of hp on stock internals for quite some time now - so has some other of his mates. Vas has told a couple of stories to...
We have danish guys running +400hp on stock 16vt, and +500hp on stock corolla 4agze. But we lack people with 20vt's, but some have tried and most of them have failed over 330hp on stock internals (although most of them has just plugged in a chip and cranked the boost). I am gonna try and push it a bit over 350hp, but with EGT and wideband AFR. Heard to many good stories from Jari and Vas to just let the opportunity pass by :-)
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: stevo]
#581204
04/04/2008 18:26
04/04/2008 18:26
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 3,158 Near Reading
JohnS
I need some sleep
|
I need some sleep
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 3,158
Near Reading
|
You cannot compare different engines stock pistons, there are a bunch of different designs, manufacturing techniques and different processes as well as different size of ring land and proximity to the squish band etc. etc. This is a well known problem with 20VT pistons that doesn't mean no stock piston can take that power. There may be a pinking or det relation to all the failures yes, but it is probably more symptomatic of how the knock circuit works in the first place. At 350BHP the amount of knock detected before the advance is backed off may be wholly inappropriate for that amount of power.
Yes Jari is running more power, but it still is a question of when not if his pistons or rods will fail.
I'm sure you'd like to think that for you it will be fine, but there are so many people on here who it wasn't fine for, and it is better to either not run the power or switch pistons and rods then it is to see a failure that takes out your crankcase/block and cylinder head
Former low boost hero - 616BHP@1.5 bar. 2.4 20VT RIP
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: JohnS]
#581208
04/04/2008 18:31
04/04/2008 18:31
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
really you can say I was lucky my engine went the way it did, as in nothing else got damaged!
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: JohnS]
#581242
04/04/2008 19:19
04/04/2008 19:19
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
At 350BHP the amount of knock detected before the advance is backed off may be wholly inappropriate for that amount of power. Also remember that the stock ECU can only back off 2 degrees, which is not always enough.
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#581598
05/04/2008 04:47
05/04/2008 04:47
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
If the car has been mapped properly, i can't see why the knock sensors should have to retard timing - detonation should not occur! And why would the maximum hp number be 330-340hp? It should be a matter of combustion heat, not hp. So if the timing is less aggressive, and the engine is getting enough fuel, it should be cooler with 350hp than a badly tuned engine with 300hp... But we'll see how it goes - i'm not saying all of you are wrong. I'm just an ignorant man who needs to learn from my own mistakes. If i trash the pistons i have en excuse to buy forged pistons I have faith in my tuners expertise, so if the thing goes pop, i know it's because we have gone beyond the limits of 20vt stock capability. Does any of you know if there has been made a new revision of 20vt pistons at some point? I saw replacement numbers in ePer awhile ago, and i just installed new, stock Fiat 20vt pistons. They were black on the skirts with some kind of coating...
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#581721
05/04/2008 16:41
05/04/2008 16:41
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 12,295 Sandhurst
Begbie
Ex El Presidente
|
Ex El Presidente
I AM a Coop
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 12,295
Sandhurst
|
And why would the maximum hp number be 330-340hp? It should be a matter of combustion heat, not hp. Have you ever thought about the pressures that happen within the cylinder as well? If you increase the power, you're going to increase the pressure in the chambers. We ar talking around 18,000psi here, and with has been said with the ringlands, they will break.
Your car is Usain Bolt with wellies
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: Begbie]
#581728
05/04/2008 16:59
05/04/2008 16:59
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
I see what you mean about pressure - i'll look a bit more in to it, but it's a good point! But there must be product tolerances - meaning that some pistons may be able to withstand 350hp and others more or less. They cant all be 100% alike... But i guess that a safe number is around 340-350! I will think about it more, but right now i'm running 1,18 bar and will probably turn it up to 1,3 and make a bigger exhaust. So should end up at around 350-360hp...
|
|
|
Re: Engine Failure - Reasons/Causes
[Re: ]
#581765
05/04/2008 18:19
05/04/2008 18:19
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
Lars_DK
Unregistered
|
That piston doesn't have the same coating, as mine do... Just worn off, or do i have a never revision?
|
|
|
|