|
1 registered members (speedy_gonzales),
669
guests, and 2
spiders. |
|
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
Forums48
Topics103,776
Posts1,170,742
Members1,683
| |
Most Online39,516 Apr 15th, 2026
|
|
|
How much power did I really have?
#810431
08/04/2009 21:34
08/04/2009 21:34
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387 Staffordshire
Nigel
OP
Forum veteran
|
OP
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387
Staffordshire
|
OK - we all know that I once managed 400bhp (405.9 to be exact) However, the car has been on several dynos since then, and its never got close (with some rolling road sessions producing some very poor results) Leighton has had the car for a couple of days to tweak the low speed and low throttle opening fuelling (using his big MAF solution). Apparently, the car is running much nicer, but he couldn't get the 400bhp that we would have liked. I'll get the graphs on Friday, but I seem to remember it was about 375bhp He DID manage a very respectable 420bhp using race fuel, which I will undoubtedly use for this year's TOTB, but my injectors were maxxed out on pump fuel. So - lets start up the debate again - how did I get 400bhp @ 1.6 bar, only to be more than 50bhp down on this at the same boost levels? Flea's session today was on a Dastek dyno Looks like I need some 440 or even 550 injectors Anyone want to buy some 384s?
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Nigel]
#810435
08/04/2009 21:37
08/04/2009 21:37
|
sediciRich
Unregistered
|
sediciRich
Unregistered
|
I'd say Nigel you didn't; I don't meen that in a harsh way at all. maybe the rr operator wanted you to feel good when parting with you money, trustworthy RR operators seem to be few and far between, and some go the other way give low results and claim you should have gone to see them first for everything.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#810454
08/04/2009 22:05
08/04/2009 22:05
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
Nigels quarter mile times and terminals point more towards 400bhp than 350. But RRs can be quite frustrating.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#810461
08/04/2009 22:13
08/04/2009 22:13
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
You probably never got 405BHP to begin with, what was your wheel figures? I maxxed my 16VT injectors at 100% duty with 3.8Bar at 370BHP, I always wondered how you got 30BHP more. This graph I have of your here is extremely wrong how can you have MAX power at the wheels & flywheel at completely different rpms? http://img16.imageshack.us/img16/1179/nigel405ftlb.jpgI don't know what went on a PT that day but I did always wonder how you managed to push those injectors so far. You need to get 440cc+ to break the 400BHP barrier.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#810500
08/04/2009 23:04
08/04/2009 23:04
|
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 5,408 Essex
Trappy
Club member 7306
|
Club member 7306
Forum is my life
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 5,408
Essex
|
This graph I have of your here is extremely wrong how can you have MAX power at the wheels & flywheel at completely different rpms?
I don't think this is hard to believe. Imagine a car's torque curve resulted in a near flat flywheel BHP for 2-3k rpms, maxing at the top end by only 1 more BHP. You'd expect the peak @ wheels power figure to be lower than the flywheel one, as parasitic losses are smaller at lower rpms. It's possible even if extremely unlikely, and probably not to the same degree as in Nigels case...
F****** b****** thing...
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Trappy]
#810513
08/04/2009 23:31
08/04/2009 23:31
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
No mate peak BHP at engine & wheels are at the same rpm no matter what.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Scuderia]
#810534
09/04/2009 04:41
09/04/2009 04:41
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
westcoupe
Unregistered
|
what was your wheel figure nigel
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#810656
09/04/2009 09:52
09/04/2009 09:52
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387 Staffordshire
Nigel
OP
Forum veteran
|
OP
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387
Staffordshire
|
what was your wheel figure nigel Can't remember - about 350 +/- 10 IIRC TurboJ - remember that I'm now on a 3.8bar FPR, which gives my 384cc injectors an equivalent of 440 (although I was using the 3 bar FPR when I got the "405.9bhp") I have a feeling I've not been told the true story  OK - I can still say I have a 400+ bhp car, its just that I need a slug of race fuel to get it Its tempting to go for bigger injectors and a GT3071, but what will I REALLY gain? - some extra ponies at the top end, which I very rarely use anyway What Leighton HAS managed to sort (with the bigger MAF) is the fuelling at other boost levels 1 bar = 300bhp 1.2 bar = 320 bhp Before, the fuelling was set for the maximum boost, but seeing as the MAF was maxxed out very early, the fuelling could ONLY be controlled with the map. Now, with a bigger maf housing and a recalibrated ECU he has the resolution to optimise the fuelling for all boost levels This means smoother running, better fuel consumption and probably more power at each boost level (at 1.2 bar previously, it WILL have been overfuelling, a it was fuelling for 1.6 bar, and thus will have made less power) The other issue that I wanted Leighton to sort was the tickover. When coming to a standstill, the tickover would often hold at 1200 - 1500 rpm for a few seconds before dropping to the usual 800. It turned out this was nothing to do with the maps - it was because of the oiliest maf that Leighton had ever seen. It would appear that my engine is a bit of a "heavy breather" and its been spitting a lot of oil mist back into the intake. Time for a crankcase breather mod, I think (although I'm going to need a catch tank for sure)
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Nigel]
#810692
09/04/2009 10:18
09/04/2009 10:18
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
although I was using the 3 bar FPR when I got the "405.9bhp"
In that case either: 1) The dyno was setup wrong 2) Rob really is hot at mapping 3) You engine produces loads of power from less fuel It would be a waste to go GT3071R, our turbo is by far the best option  . Now that you have got your ECU sorted yet again I would suggest the bigger injectors, but then that requires more mapping  . P.S. This oil everywhere is a concern I would look into it.
Last edited by TurboJ; 09/04/2009 10:27. Reason: Added
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#810721
09/04/2009 10:45
09/04/2009 10:45
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 5,405 Castle Combe
Flea
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 5,405
Castle Combe
|
Yes it was oily!! After seeing that, I was surprised it could measure any air at all. Anyway, after a good clean it still works and the strange idle problem has now gone. The Big MAF conversion has achieved the desired goal and that is to run a greater range of boost. The car is now mapped for four boost settings on the Blitz: 1bar 1.2bar 1.5bar 2bar As Nigel has already mentioned, it would appear that no matter which dyno it goes to (Dyno Dynamics/MAHA/Dastek), it cannot reach the heady heights that it once did at PT so it certainly begs the question. That said, it feels very fast on the road and very capable. Anyway the results from yesterday: Pump Fuel1bar - 309bhp & 255lbs/ft 1.2bar - 329bhp & 277lbs/ft 1.5bar - 352bhp & 309lbs/ft 1.95bar - 363bhp & 348lbs/ft Race Fuel1.5bar - 412bhp & 336lbs/ft 1.95bar - 420bhp & 363lbs/ft The problem being the injectors were struggling at anything over 1.2bar where even then they hit 100% duty at 7300rpm. At 1.5bar 85% duty @ 5500rpm, 100% @ 6300rpm. At 2bar they hit 85% @ 4500rpm and 100% @ 5300rpm. The injectors actually go static at around 6000rpm so totally out of control. Thankfully it is not as bad on the road, that is they don't go static so the fueling is controllable and the duty slightly less. I would estimate there is 10-15bhp being lost due to the injectors at high rpm. It never ends! In that case either: 1) The dyno was setup wrong 2) Rob really is hot at mapping 3) You engine produces loads of power from less fuel
Just to comment on your three points. 1. Perhaps... 2. The irony being Nigel's worst result was 270bhp @ 1.7bar on a Dyno Dynamics with the original PT map. 3. Actually Nigels car runs better slightly rich as it doesn't respond too well to timing like some. However there is simply no way at 3bar fuel pressure you could have safe fueling on those injectors, they would be at 100% duty long before.
Last edited by Flea; 09/04/2009 11:04.
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Flea]
#810813
09/04/2009 12:32
09/04/2009 12:32
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
I defiantly agree with you on the injectors side. Really an injector shouldn't be pushed more than 85-90%. Certainly not 100% they need time to be closed. If your findings are true (no doubt that they are) I would strongly suggest Nigel to upgrade his injectors before going past 1.2Bar regardless of it being safer on the road, especially if he plans on running at TOTB. 1.95bar - 363bhp & 348lbs/ft I find this result very interesting and a new target for me. Since I have a very similar setup and my is going on a Dyno Dynamics soon this is my target  so Nigel watch out  TOTB here I come  Can you release his WBHP also? Now the next question what is all that oil from????
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#810944
09/04/2009 16:06
09/04/2009 16:06
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387 Staffordshire
Nigel
OP
Forum veteran
|
OP
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387
Staffordshire
|
AR$E  last time the car was with Leighton, the thermostat failed (closed) and the car had to be recovered. Today, he was just finishing the low-throttle mapping and the coolant hose of death has burst (third time in 5 years) Time for another mod........
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Nigel]
#810974
09/04/2009 16:38
09/04/2009 16:38
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
Just not your week is it 
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: pinin_prestatyn]
#811177
09/04/2009 20:15
09/04/2009 20:15
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
you don't have much luck do you
As has been said above you probably never made 400bhp, the maths never did add up with regard to bhp vs injector size from what I had been told but that just further impresses me with your driving ability and the cornering agility of a well setup coupe
Get some bigger injectors in there and you will be up there in the figures that you should be getting with your setup
Also I know I keep banging on about it but WBHP would be helpfull and they may be closer figures than what your getting on other dynos
Ricky
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#811235
09/04/2009 21:12
09/04/2009 21:12
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387 Staffordshire
Nigel
OP
Forum veteran
|
OP
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387
Staffordshire
|
Ricky - not sure what graphs Leighton took away from the dyno, but I guess I'll get them all tomorrow when I pick the car up However, I'm pretty sure that Leighton mentioned 320 at the wheels, which would tally quite well with several other dyno sessions I've done. So - its seems you don't need 400bhp to be competitive at TOTB, just 350 and some sticky tyres  Thankfully, Motormech as a coolant hose in stock, so I'll pick it up first thing, then trudge down the M5 to Bristol to get it fitted
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: pinin_prestatyn]
#811297
09/04/2009 22:12
09/04/2009 22:12
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Yeah, 320 sounds about right for what others are getting with the 16vt injectors
Also I'm sure there was more than sticky tyres that contributed to your performance at TOTB
Anyway your only restriction seems to be the injectors, sort that and you should be on for maxing out the turbo, obviously if you still wish to persue the 400bhp
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#811754
10/04/2009 18:26
10/04/2009 18:26
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387 Staffordshire
Nigel
OP
Forum veteran
|
OP
Forum veteran
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 17,387
Staffordshire
|
yup - looking for 440 or even 550 injectors now
These are the final figures
Pump fuel
1.0 bar - 309bhp (268bhp ATW), 255 lb-ft 1.2 bar - 329bhp (289bhp ATW), 277 lb-ft 1.5 bar - 351bhp (316bhp ATW), 308 lb-ft 1.95 bar - 363bhp (324bhp ATW), 347 lb-ft
The 1.95 bar figure is a bit misleading - on the graph, the area under the curve is much bigger, which should give far better performance when on the road
Race fuel
1.2 bar - 385bhp (346bhp ATW), 317 lb-ft 1.5 bar - 392bhp (354bhp ATW), 349 lb-ft 1.95 bar - 400.8bhp (362bhp ATW), 363 lb-ft
Looking at the power at 1.2 bar, why would anyone want to run 50% more boost for 15bhp more? I guess its a consequence of my maxxed out injectors that the 1.95 bar run didn't give a lot more
Leighton also did a run using a different dyno mode and saw 420bhp (381 ATW) and 358 lb-ft
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Nigel]
#811776
10/04/2009 19:11
10/04/2009 19:11
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
You've got me worried that I'm going to need larger than 440's now!
Its quite interesting that you can only get enough fuel for 360bhp on pump fuel with 16VT injectors and 3.8bar fpr when quite a few people got this power with standard injectors and fpr. DocFrag, Flea, Squid??
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#811807
10/04/2009 19:46
10/04/2009 19:46
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
TurboJ
Unregistered
|
Dyno Dynamics should be set to "shoot out" mode "6 cylinder" they don't have a 5 pot mode yet  . Those figures look more real. It is very important that the dyno operator has the dyno setup properly and the corrections are set too. A dyno is only as good as the guy operating it. That was clearly not the case for PT on your day however my results seem to tie in with yours even though it was done at PT and yours by Flea. I maxxed out my 384cc with the figures below. 1.7 Bar - 352BHP (322WBHP), 340 lb-ft Anyway how much more mapping is required to get your car sorted on the 440/550? Surely that will change everything and basically have to start the whole process from scratch 
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#811812
10/04/2009 20:00
10/04/2009 20:00
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Ok, i have used an injector calculator to work some things out for the benifit of others
This is what i have
16vt injectors are 384cc at 3 bar, at 3.8 bar they produce 432cc
440cc injectors are 495cc at 3.8 bar
The BHP figures i am quoting below are flywheel figures
For 360 bhp @ 3 bar FP @ 80% duty you will need 618cc injectors
The same but with 3.8 bar you will need 547cc
For 400bhp @ 3 bar and 80% duty you will need 687cc injectors
the same but with 3.8 bar you will need 608cc
450bhp @ 3 bar and 80% duty you will need 773cc injectors
the same with 3.8 bar you will need 683cc injectors
the same as above but at 85% duty you will need 643cc injectors
for 400bhp @ 85% duty with 3.8 bar you will need572cc injectors
Also for you eldinho the 440's at 3.8 bar and 95% duty you can only manage 390bhp
And using the same calculator the 16vt injectors @ 100 duty and 3.8 bar will max out at 360BHP, this seems to tie in with the figures being produced
100% duty is far to much, even 85% is 5% over most manufacturers recomendations but is safe in my eyes
I do not like running injectors past 85% duty but i have run them at 90% with no ill effect but i would never recomend it
All of the figures above are on the safe side of the limit and you will be able to get a bit more but not with out pushing well out of the manufacturers recomended pressures and duty
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Flea]
#811864
10/04/2009 22:15
10/04/2009 22:15
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
Trickymex
Unregistered
|
well if you like review them but these are figures a got on 4 different web based injector calculators and a calculator that cosworth use
They were all done using a 0.65 brake specific fuel consumption, that's recomended by most, and obviously done with 5 injectors in those calculations
I have used the same calculators on many builds and they always have come pretty much spot on everytime
On top of that Jason and nigel have topped out at near enough the exact figures that the calculator said
Anyway let me know your results and also what calculator your using
Ricky
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: ]
#811869
10/04/2009 22:25
10/04/2009 22:25
|
Akeme
Unregistered
|
Akeme
Unregistered
|
Nigel, have you done a compression test recently by any chance?
|
|
|
Re: How much power did I really have?
[Re: Nigel]
#811954
11/04/2009 10:32
11/04/2009 10:32
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 5,405 Castle Combe
Flea
Forum is my life
|
Forum is my life
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 5,405
Castle Combe
|
Nigel, you missed run 6 on the race fuel which gave 401bhp & 363lbs/ft  I did do a comp test a couple of months back and all was good. Tricky, I have used the injector calculators before and they struggle to fit the coupe 5 pot for some reason. I base this on real world data which in Nigel's case is as follows: Nigel's injectors are 384cc @ 3bar so 432cc @ 3.8bar. Using 0.65 B.S.F.C, 300bhp would require 482cc @ 85% duty. The reality is Nigel achieved 300bhp at 71% injector duty, the calculator suggests this would require 576cc. If we lower the B.S.F.C to 0.50 then it requires 444cc which is a lot more realistic and correlates with the actual data. This is the same for the standard injectors which are 330cc @ 3bar. These invariably reach 90-100% duty around 290-310bhp. Again using the calculator: B.S.F.C 0.65 @ 220bhp = 353cc @ 85% duty 0.65 @ 250bhp = 401cc @ 85% duty 0.65 @ 300bhp = 482cc @ 85% duty Now we know Fiat wouldn't build a factory car with power exceeding 85% injector duty which is what the above confirms. Also, we know a chipped 20vt doesn't need 400cc injectors! However, if we go with the 0.50 B.S.F.C it once again correlates with the real world data. B.S.F.C 0.50 @ 220bhp = 330cc @ 70% duty 0.50 @ 250bhp = 330cc @ 79% duty 0.50 @ 300bhp = 330cc @ 95% duty Moving this up to 340bhp i.e. RSR or RS turbos, many coupes use the standard injectors at 3.8bar so 380cc flow this would suggest 94% max duty. For 400bhp this would require 450cc injectors @ 93%. So for Nigel to comfortably make 400bhp @ 85% duty I would recommend 440cc innjectors @ 3.8bar i.e. 496cc
|
|
|
|